Florida resident fined by HOA, accusing him of running an LLC out of his home, resident forced to pay $1k or spend up to $5k to fight it

Advertisement
  • A homeowner crosses his arms in front of his suburban neighborhood.
  • HOA fined me $1,000 and is now saying I run a business out of my house

    A couple months ago I posted about my HOA fining me $1,000 over parking violations and originally accusing me of running a detailing business out of my house (I don't - I just have a mobile detailer come work on my cars). That turned into a bunch of parking-related violations (street,
  • sidewalk, "overnight" at the amenity center), and at my hearing the committee couldn't even answer basic questions like what "overnight" means or what fine amount they were imposing.
  • They sent a $100 fine first, then 3 days later a $1,000 fine for the same thing. I dug into Florida statute and their own governing docs and sent a pretty detailed dispute pointing out issues with
  • the process and the lack of actual evidence. I also sent a certified letter to make sure it was formally received. None of it was ever responded to.
  • Right after I sent that dispute, the community manager quit. No explanation, just gone.
  • A quiet residential area with red, green, and yellow bushes.
  • Separately, I also received a Facebook message from the HOA president's wife that was pretty aggressive about the situation,
  • which didn't exactly help things feel like they were being handled professionally.
  • Now instead of addressing anything I raised, the HOA hired an attorney and sent me a presuit mediation notice. But the weird part is they've completely pivoted
  • their argument. Now they're saying I'm operating a business out of my house. Their "evidence" is that I have LLCs registered at my address and that I post cars on social media.
  • That's literally it. No customers come to my house, no services are done there, it's just where I live.
  • I talked to a lawyer and was told if | go through mediation I'm probably looking at $3k-$5k total just to deal with this. So now I'm stuck choosing between paying $1,000 for something I don't think is even valid, or spending way more to fight it.
  • Two lawyers communicate in a meeting, seated near a gavel with only their hands shown.
  • At this point I emailed their attorney and basically said I'll pay the $1,000 if they confirm everything is closed out, my account is at zero, and they're not going to keep coming after me over the same allegations. Waiting to hear back.
  • Honestly I'm just annoyed. Not even about the money as much as the fact that they made incorrect assumptions, ignored me (even via certified letter), and
  • then escalated it instead of fixing anything. Now I'm the one stuck paying just to be done with it.
  • A homeowner crosses his arms in front of his suburban neighborhood.
  • Am I being dumb settling this, or is this just one of those situations where it's not worth the time and money to fight?
  • TLDR: HOA fined me $1k, ignored my dispute (including a certified letter), manager quit, I got a hostile message from the president's wife, and now their lawyer says I'm running a business out of my house based on LLCs and social media.
  • Mediation will cost more than the fine so I'm trying to settle and move on.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article